The implementation of sticky notes in rt-xr opened a whole can of worms but really just forced the development of a set of capabilities that will be needed for the general case where occupants of a sentient space can download assets from anywhere, instantiate them in a space and then interact with them. In particular, the need to be able to create a sticky note, position it and add text to it when being used on the supported platforms (Windows and mac OS desktop, Android, iOS and Windows Mixed Reality) required a surprising amount of work. I decided to standardize on a three button mouse model and map the various interaction styles into mouse events. This means that the bulk of the code doesn’t need to care about the interaction style (mouse, motion controller, touch screen etc) as all the complexity is housed in one script.
The short video below shows this in operation on a Windows desktop.
It ended up running a bit fast but that was due to the video recorder setup – I can’t really do things that fast!
I am still just using opaque devices – where is my HoloLens 2 or Magic Leap?!!! However, things should map across pretty well. Note how the current objects are glued to the virtual walls. Using MR devices, the spatial maps would be used for raycasting so that the objects would be glued to the real walls. I do need to add a mode where you can pull things off walls and position them arbitrarily in space but that’s just a TODO right now.
What doesn’t yet work is sharing of these actions. When an object is moved, that move should be visible to all occupants of the space. Likewise, when a new object is created or text updated on a sticky note, everyone should see that. That’s the next step, followed by making all of this persistent.
Anyway, here is how interaction works on the various platforms.
Windows and mac OS desktop
For Windows, the assumption is that three button (middle wheel) mouse is used. The middle button is used to grab and position objects. The right mouse button opens up the menu for that object. The left button is used for selection and resizing. On the Mac, which doesn’t have a middle button, the middle button is simulated by holding down the Command key which maps the left button into the middle button.
Navigation is via the SpaceMouse on both platforms.
Windows Mixed Reality
The motion controllers have quite a few controls and buttons available. I am using the Grab button to grab and position objects. The trigger is used for selection and resizing while the menu button is used to bring up the object menu. Pointing at the sticky note and pressing the trigger causes the virtual keyboard to appear.
Navigation uses the standard joystick-based teleport system.
Android and iOS
My solution here is a little ugly. Basically, the number of fingers used for a tap and/or hold dictates which mouse button the action maps to. A single touch means the left mouse button, two touches means the right mouse button while three touches means the middle button. It works but it is pretty amusing trying to get three simultaneous touches on an object to initiate a grab on a small screen device like a phone!
Navigation is via single or dual touch. Single touch and slide moves in x and y directions. Dual touch and slide rotates around the y axis. Since touches are used for other things, navigation touches need to be made away from objects or else they will be misinterpreted. Probably there is a better way of doing this. However, in the longer term, see-through mode using something like ARCore or ARKit will eliminate the navigation issue which is only a problem in VR (opaque) mode. I assume the physical occupants of a space will use see-through mode with only remote occupants using VR mode.
I haven’t been using ARCore or ARKit yet, mainly because they haven’t seemed good enough to create a spatial map that is useful for rt-xr. This is changing (ARKit 2 for example) but the question is whether it can cope with multiple rooms. For example, objects behind a real wall should not be visible – they need to be occluded by the spatial map. The HoloLens can do this however and is the best available option right now for multi-room MR with persistence.